CONTINUE READING...

Become a member of Good Food Guide+ to unlock Britain’s 100 Best Local Restaurants 2026 on 13 July, plus get unlimited access to our reviews, newsletters and the best local restaurants, bakeries and pubs around Britain.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Already have an account? Log in

The Punch Bowl Inn

Cumbria, Crosthwaite - Modern British - Pub with rooms - ££

Overall Rating: Good

Uniqueness:Does the establishment stand out in the context of the local area? Good

Deliciousness:How delicious is the food? Good

Warmth:How warm is the service and the hospitality in general? Good

Strength of recommendation:How enthusiastically and widely would you recommend the establishment? Good

A serene village in the verdant Lyth Valley, complete with a pretty church and rolling hills, is home to this upmarket hostelry. Originally a blacksmith's forge at the beginning of the 19th century, its old bones make for a magnificent country inn, where beams and slates, real fires and real ales feel right at home across several spaces. It's been a dining destination for several decades and continues to deliver a menu that keeps its feet firmly on the ground, with produce from the owners' farm ensuring that food miles are kept to a minimum. Lancashire cheese soufflé with caramelised red onions is a cross-border favourite, comforting and rich, or you could try a lighter option such as beetroot and pomegranate salad with goat's cheese and raspberry vinaigrette. Cumbrian lamb arrives with a miniature shepherd's pie, while fish might feature pan-roasted cod with cider and mussel sauce, plus a serving of mash to soak it all up. During the week, lunchtime brings similar dishes...

A serene village in the verdant Lyth Valley, complete with a pretty church and rolling hills, is home to this upmarket hostelry. Originally a blacksmith's forge at the beginning of the 19th century, its old bones make for a magnificent country inn, where beams and slates, real fires and real ales feel right at home across several spaces. It's been a dining destination for several decades and continues to deliver a menu that keeps its feet firmly on the ground, with produce from the owners' farm ensuring that food miles are kept to a minimum.

Lancashire cheese soufflé with caramelised red onions is a cross-border favourite, comforting and rich, or you could try a lighter option such as beetroot and pomegranate salad with goat's cheese and raspberry vinaigrette. Cumbrian lamb arrives with a miniature shepherd's pie, while fish might feature pan-roasted cod with cider and mussel sauce, plus a serving of mash to soak it all up.

During the week, lunchtime brings similar dishes, with the addition of pub staples such as fish and chips or local wild boar and damson sausages (with mash and gravy). Those damsons also appear as a sorbet with the Punch Bowl's renowned lemon tart. Sunday lunch (a weekly changing blow-out) brings roast beef sirloin with Yorkies and seasonal vegetables (some courtesy of the owner's farm). Well-chosen wines from £27.

Read full reviewSee less

J Thompson

29 June 2026

We enjoyed dinner at The Punch Bowl Inn on a Sunday evening stopover. The service from a large number of staff was prompt and warm. The food was high quality and we chose many of the items listed in the Guide’s review....
We enjoyed dinner at The Punch Bowl Inn on a Sunday evening stopover. The service from a large number of staff was prompt and warm. The food was high quality and we chose many of the items listed in the Guide’s review. The Cheese Soufflé starter was excellent and the Cumbrian Lamb main course featured beautifully pink pieces of loin. The wine list covers all bases and includes a good selection available by the glass. We stayed overnight; the bedroom was very comfortable and, despite being the...
We enjoyed dinner at The Punch Bowl Inn on a Sunday evening stopover. The service from a large number of staff was prompt and warm. The food was high quality and we chose many of the items listed in the Guide’s review. The Cheese Soufflé starter was excellent and the Cumbrian Lamb main course featured beautifully pink pieces of loin. The wine list covers all bases and includes a good selection available by the glass. We stayed overnight; the bedroom was very comfortable and, despite being the smallest of nine, spacious. The quality of the breakfast was in line with that of dinner the previous evening. Well worth a visit and we will return.
See MoreSee less

j martin

20 April 2026

Food is amazing with good choices for all. The lunch menu is slightly reduced but still meets their high standards. The cheese souffle is 'to die for'

L Housden

9 September 2025

The cheese soufflé was out of this world. Excellent selection of wines and the pork belly main was delicious.

VENUE DETAILS

Lyth Valley
Crosthwaite
Cumbria
LA8 8HRGB

015395 68237

Make a reservation

OTHER INFORMATION

Accommodation, Separate bar, Wheelchair access, Parking, Electric car charging, Dog friendly, Credit card required, Deposit required

Latest articles