Best Local Restaurant

CONTINUE READING...

Become a member of Good Food Guide+ to unlock ⁠Britain’s 100 Best Local Restaurants 2026, and get unlimited access to our reviews, newsletters and other lists including the best bakeries and pubs around Britain

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Already have an account? Log in

The Gordon Arms

Borders, Selkirk - Modern Scottish - Restaurant - ££

Family-run venue showcasing local hospitality and local ingredients

Overall Rating: Good

Uniqueness:Does the establishment stand out in the context of the local area? Good

Deliciousness:How delicious is the food? Good

Warmth:How warm is the service and the hospitality in general? Very Good

Strength of recommendation:How enthusiastically and widely would you recommend the establishment? Good

‘Great food, magnificent countryside and no passport queues!’ cheered one reporter, while another simply proclaimed, ‘This is all about happiness’. They were referring to the tastefully refreshed Gordon Arms – a fine old coaching inn, now a family-run restaurant with rooms. Guests are drawn into the comforting solidity of well-banked fires, convivial chat and a sense of respite from travel, while seasonality, sustainability and local sourcing are the kitchen’s watchwords. There’s a keen eye for value, too, although eating here also feels ‘elegant and exclusive’. Expect carefully prepared, rustic food from a chef who understands the quality of his raw materials and is content to let them shine: Yarrow Valley venison salami, wild garlic from the Ettrick Valley, beef from the Borders’ herds, and a veritable harvest festival of pickings from the orchard and garden. Elsewhere, honey from the glen is used to dress a ricotta-stuffed ...

‘Great food, magnificent countryside and no passport queues!’ cheered one reporter, while another simply proclaimed, ‘This is all about happiness’. They were referring to the tastefully refreshed Gordon Arms – a fine old coaching inn, now a family-run restaurant with rooms. Guests are drawn into the comforting solidity of well-banked fires, convivial chat and a sense of respite from travel, while seasonality, sustainability and local sourcing are the kitchen’s watchwords. There’s a keen eye for value, too, although eating here also feels ‘elegant and exclusive’. Expect carefully prepared, rustic food from a chef who understands the quality of his raw materials and is content to let them shine: Yarrow Valley venison salami, wild garlic from the Ettrick Valley, beef from the Borders’ herds, and a veritable harvest festival of pickings from the orchard and garden. Elsewhere, honey from the glen is used to dress a ricotta-stuffed courgette flower, while rare-breed pork loin might be paired with ‘nduja-spiced chickpeas. The wine list is well-focused, with some interesting options and a decent selection by the glass or carafe.

 

Read full reviewSee less

J Eustace

25 April 2026

This is all about happiness! Almost living in plain sight, The Gordon Arms resides in beautiful surroundings, equalled by all that, wonderful hospitality. The attention to detail, be it front of house or simply outstandi...
This is all about happiness! Almost living in plain sight, The Gordon Arms resides in beautiful surroundings, equalled by all that, wonderful hospitality. The attention to detail, be it front of house or simply outstanding cuisine placed in front of us is almost from a forgotten era of dedication to pleasing the customer. Equally, they don't give lip service to sustainability they practice it in all they do without losing any taste to savour. Early asparagus, risotto, and a dessert from 'the lad...
This is all about happiness! Almost living in plain sight, The Gordon Arms resides in beautiful surroundings, equalled by all that, wonderful hospitality. The attention to detail, be it front of house or simply outstanding cuisine placed in front of us is almost from a forgotten era of dedication to pleasing the customer. Equally, they don't give lip service to sustainability they practice it in all they do without losing any taste to savour. Early asparagus, risotto, and a dessert from 'the lady who bakes' created a wonderful meal this evening. An excellent wine list and the water from their own spring another couple of pluses. Sum up? Wonderful almost hidden location, comfortable bedrooms, excellent showers, but most all the place exudes kindness and happiness, all too rare as we all know
See MoreSee less

S Timmins

19 April 2026

The husband and wife team have created an extraordinary dining experience using many local products with a flair for style. The food is excellent, the atmosphere warm and cozy and the staff is great! We love it! Well worth the trip to this establishment!

F Blyth

19 April 2026

Fantastic food, great location. A lovely husband and wife team. Very professional but friendly and approachable. Uses as much local produce possible. They don't pack in the tables, it elegant and exclusive. The food is absolutely delicious with superb wine choices

W Redpath

10 February 2025

We went for lunch on Saturday, 8th February 2025. The food was exceptional, from the starters of artichoke soup and smoked haddock with pickled beetroot and crème fresh, The mains were so delicious, and the sea bass was...
We went for lunch on Saturday, 8th February 2025. The food was exceptional, from the starters of artichoke soup and smoked haddock with pickled beetroot and crème fresh, The mains were so delicious, and the sea bass was so good, along with lovely broccoli and fresh new potatoes. The other main was a wood pigeon on a bed of warm salad with haggis and black pudding. We both finished with drunken cherry pudding and chocolate ice cream. We would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for...
We went for lunch on Saturday, 8th February 2025. The food was exceptional, from the starters of artichoke soup and smoked haddock with pickled beetroot and crème fresh, The mains were so delicious, and the sea bass was so good, along with lovely broccoli and fresh new potatoes. The other main was a wood pigeon on a bed of warm salad with haggis and black pudding. We both finished with drunken cherry pudding and chocolate ice cream. We would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a place out of the way in the beautiful Yarrow Valley. The service was very good and relaxed. Definitely go again.
See MoreSee less

VENUE DETAILS

Yarrow Valley
Selkirk
Borders
TD7 5LEGB

01750 82261

Make a reservation

OTHER INFORMATION

Accommodation, Private dining room, Separate bar, Wheelchair access, Parking, Dog friendly, Credit card required

Latest articles