Best Local Restaurant

CONTINUE READING...

Sign up to receive our free newsletters, or for just £1.25 a month become a member and get unlimited access to Good Food Guide content & reviews.

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Already have an account? Log in

Edie’s

Cornwall, St Austell - British - Restaurant - ££

Likeable neighbourhood spot with bags of sympathetic charm

Overall Rating: Good

Uniqueness:Does the establishment stand out in the context of the local area? Good

Deliciousness:How delicious is the food? Good

Warmth:How warm is the service and the hospitality in general? Good

Strength of recommendation:How enthusiastically and widely would you recommend the establishment? Good

Above Carlyon Bay, at one end of a parade of shops and cafés behind an area of off-road parking, there is more culinary glamour to Edie's than might first appear. Co-owner and chef Nigel Brown has done stints at Le Manoir aux Quat'Saisons and at the late Bill Granger's Sydney restaurant. Inside, the place feels like a true neighbourhood spot, not least because it is run with such sympathetic charm. Contemporary brasserie cooking is the name of the game, with a good-value fixed-price menu supplementing an appreciably adventurous carte. First off might be a dazzling salad of Isle of Wight tomatoes with pickled shallots, pangrattato, whipped feta and basil oil, an energising blaze of colour. Much is made of the starter soufflés, perhaps Comté cheese with spinach and wild mushroom fricassée. Soft gnudi make a satisfying lunchtime main, accompanied by a riot of spring veg in lemon butter with crumbled sourdough croûtes adding crunch, while fish dishes...

Above Carlyon Bay, at one end of a parade of shops and cafés behind an area of off-road parking, there is more culinary glamour to Edie's than might first appear. Co-owner and chef Nigel Brown has done stints at Le Manoir aux Quat'Saisons and at the late Bill Granger's Sydney restaurant. Inside, the place feels like a true neighbourhood spot, not least because it is run with such sympathetic charm.

Contemporary brasserie cooking is the name of the game, with a good-value fixed-price menu supplementing an appreciably adventurous carte. First off might be a dazzling salad of Isle of Wight tomatoes with pickled shallots, pangrattato, whipped feta and basil oil, an energising blaze of colour. Much is made of the starter soufflés, perhaps Comté cheese with spinach and wild mushroom fricassée. Soft gnudi make a satisfying lunchtime main, accompanied by a riot of spring veg in lemon butter with crumbled sourdough croûtes adding crunch, while fish dishes are all you might expect for the location – maybe halibut with brown shrimps and saffron potatoes in curry sauce. Fillet steaks with hand-cut chips, watercress and Café de Paris butter will be a dead cert for a large proportion of the clientele.

Finish with elderflower panna cotta, yoghurt sorbet and lemon curd or – if you missed its savoury cousin earlier on – a raspberry soufflé with rum anglaise and vanilla ice cream. The short, helpfully annotated wine list has reasonable mark-ups, with glasses from £5.25.

Read full reviewSee less

C Cox

13 April 2026

You feel like you’re going to a friend’s house for dinner. The welcome is warm and friendly, with hugs! The food is exceptional and the service second to none. The locals frequent Edie’s more than tourists or passers by. It is loved by many and rightly so.

t bourne

13 April 2026

from the minute you step into the building, you are greeted like you are one of their friends. regular or not. from the local produce that is from independent micro herb growers to local fishmongers and veg supplies and alcohol on their shelves. everything about this restaurant is local. edie’s is community.

A PAYNE

12 April 2026

We have just visited Edie’s for the first time and from the moment we stepped through the door we felt like this was a special place. The opening page of the menu says: “ If you're feeling a little low (and it's noth...
We have just visited Edie’s for the first time and from the moment we stepped through the door we felt like this was a special place. The opening page of the menu says: “ If you're feeling a little low (and it's nothing to do with us!), please don't hesitate to let us know. We'll always do our best to lift your spirits with something delicious and a little extra kindness - that's what we're here for.” I took a photo and copied the text here. It made me tear up as I’ve never seen anything...
We have just visited Edie’s for the first time and from the moment we stepped through the door we felt like this was a special place. The opening page of the menu says: “ If you're feeling a little low (and it's nothing to do with us!), please don't hesitate to let us know. We'll always do our best to lift your spirits with something delicious and a little extra kindness - that's what we're here for.” I took a photo and copied the text here. It made me tear up as I’ve never seen anything like that and I’ve often felt like I need a little extra kindness. Today I didn’t, but we still got service and food with a heart. Today everything I ate was unlike anything I’d eaten before. Monkfish to start, hake for main and chocolate tart for pudding. All the dishes unique and delicious. As someone who doesn’t drink, I really appreciated the range of alcohol-free options. I even overheard a waitress chatting to another table about it after they’d commented on the menu; it felt completely normal and unforced, which says a lot about the place. Wonderful.
See MoreSee less

R Mitchell

18 January 2026

I ate Confit duck salad, followed by Hake with a warm tartar sauce and finished with a Black fig soufflé. The staff are always very welcoming and attentive at Edie’s making for an enjoyable evening. What is really special is the exceptional food. Every dish was spot on last night, The restaurant was really busy and yet all the dishes arrived beautifully cooked, a good temperature, artistically presented and melt in the mouth delicious as though each dish had been cooked just for me.

K Taws

9 October 2024

Really good atmosphere in quite a simple but welcoming dining room. Service was very good throughout; it was friendly and professional, with nice timing for initial drinks, starters, and then mains. We had a table near t...
Really good atmosphere in quite a simple but welcoming dining room. Service was very good throughout; it was friendly and professional, with nice timing for initial drinks, starters, and then mains. We had a table near the pass, and the only downside was that absolutely everything looked fantastic and really well presented, which made selecting dishes very difficult! Everything was cooked to perfection. Both fish dishes were well-balanced, with excellent accompaniments. The chicken had a superb ...
Really good atmosphere in quite a simple but welcoming dining room. Service was very good throughout; it was friendly and professional, with nice timing for initial drinks, starters, and then mains. We had a table near the pass, and the only downside was that absolutely everything looked fantastic and really well presented, which made selecting dishes very difficult! Everything was cooked to perfection. Both fish dishes were well-balanced, with excellent accompaniments. The chicken had a superb baba ghanoush, and my fillet was cooked perfectly and was a lovely cut of meat. We mainly had wines by the glass, but the wine list was very well-priced compared to many places, and there was a good selection. I would not hesitate to recommend Edie's.
See MoreSee less

VENUE DETAILS

10 Beach Road, Carlyon Bay
St Austell
Cornwall
PL25 3PH GB

01726 813888

Make a reservation

OTHER INFORMATION

Parking, Family friendly, Credit card required

Latest articles