It’s not much of a stretch to consider the young baseball-capped chef Elliot Hashtroudi a modern-day Heston Blumenthal. After grafting at
St John and striking out on his own with standout residencies at Carousel (half a deep-fried pig’s head? Yes please) and 107 Wine Bar, he made a splash with his debut restaurant
Camille and its unapologetically offal-forward menu of bladder and stomach and ears and trotters dressed up in appealing Francophone dishes at the dinky Borough Market bistro.
His second restaurant, B. Penhale, which opened this week, has been years in his mind’s eye and unearths sidelined culinary traditions from around the British Isles. There’s mock turtle soup (calf’s brain in a clear beef consommé) and skuets (sweetbreads, bacon and kidney) dragged in from the 1700s alongside desserts like Whim Wham, a Scottish take on a trifle from the Regency period, and kitsch-y 80s classics.

It’s clever. For one thing, even a seen-it-all-before restaurant buff will need help translating the menu. In a world of lookalike seasonal small plate menus, it feels delightfully novel to have to ask three times what partan bree is (a rice-thickened crab soup from north-east Scotland). Secondly, it’s the ultimate destination for visitors touching down in London looking for an authentic flavour of our food culture beyond fish and chips and beef Wellington. Already the jellied eels set in aspic has attracted intrigue from overseas acquaintances on my Instagram. They’re certainly more appetising than the under-seasoned pie and mash shop variety.

But it’s not all offal and obscure dishes. Snacks open with generously sturdy slices of Irish treacle soda bread, served just-warm so the butter melts gently into it. There’s egg and soldiers, Cumberland sausage in glossy gravy and comforting Dublin coddle. A towering salad of winter leaves is dressed with salad cream and there are sides of silky colcannon or chips with Irish curry sauce. On the white-clothed tables, alongside brassy chamberstick candle holders, are old-school salt and pepper shakers, kitsch mustard pots and your own vinegar to souse your chips to your heart’s content.

In fact, this sense of fun is the best part about Penhale’s. Despite what appears at first glance to be a very grown-up and glossy setting – the beautiful Victorian marbled walls set the tone somewhat – the menu and the sharply dressed, oft-moustached front of house team really do inspire a come-as-you-are attitude. There might be a superb selection of grower Champagne but no one will be judging if you prefer a pint of Tennent’s, or even an Irn Bru to slake your thirst.
When Hashtroudi and co-owners Clare Lattin and Tom Hill were looking for a new site, they had designs on the restaurant-packed grid of Soho but here, on the doorstep of Smithfield Market where Hashtroudi’s great-grandmother once worked as a butcher, makes so much more sense. The building dates back to 1906 when it was a Lyons tea room (note the tea and biscuits on offer once you’ve paid your bill) and is ensconced in the even more historic setting of St Bartholemew’s church yard.
Perhaps the most important part of the history, though, is Betty Penhale, Hashtroudi’s maternal grandmother – a prolific home cook for whom the restaurant is named and from whence the chef’s talents are presumably drawn. If she could see this gilded, gloriously whimsical celebration of British and Irish food culture, I’m sure she’d be fiercely proud.