CONTINUE READING...

Become a member of Good Food Guide+ to see Britain’s 50 Best Bakeries 2026 and get unlimited access to our reviews, newsletters and the best local restaurants and pubs around Britain.

Already have an account? Log in

The Black Swan

North Yorkshire, Oldstead - Modern British - Restaurant with rooms - ££££

Reconfigured Yorkshire inn excelling at 'farm to fork' cooking

Overall Rating: Very Good

Uniqueness:Does the establishment stand out in the context of the local area? Very Good

Deliciousness:How delicious is the food? Very Good

Warmth:How warm is the service and the hospitality in general? Good

Strength of recommendation:How enthusiastically and widely would you recommend the establishment? Very Good

A shining beacon on the edge of the romantically desolate North York Moors, the Black Swan is a stone-built inn, now more obviously a regional restaurant with rooms. Inside, it has been daringly reconfigured for its contemporary purpose, with spare modern furniture and unclothed tables against a backdrop of thick stone and heavy beams. Former civil servant Alice Power is the latest incumbent in the Swan's kitchen, disposing over two acres of kitchen garden, overseeing a tireless foraging operation, and maintaining the format of a lengthy taster of around a dozen stages – a menu structure that crucially depends on robust endurance. That said, there is no sense of overload about these dishes, largely because they don't go heavy on carbs. First nibbles evoke excited first impressions, from smoked eel and oscietra caviar with fennel pollen to a bite-sized chunk of truffled roe deer with celeriac. Foraged ingredients provide the haunting aromatics in dishes ranging from scallop...

A shining beacon on the edge of the romantically desolate North York Moors, the Black Swan is a stone-built inn, now more obviously a regional restaurant with rooms. Inside, it has been daringly reconfigured for its contemporary purpose, with spare modern furniture and unclothed tables against a backdrop of thick stone and heavy beams.

Former civil servant Alice Power is the latest incumbent in the Swan's kitchen, disposing over two acres of kitchen garden, overseeing a tireless foraging operation, and maintaining the format of a lengthy taster of around a dozen stages – a menu structure that crucially depends on robust endurance. That said, there is no sense of overload about these dishes, largely because they don't go heavy on carbs.

First nibbles evoke excited first impressions, from smoked eel and oscietra caviar with fennel pollen to a bite-sized chunk of truffled roe deer with celeriac. Foraged ingredients provide the haunting aromatics in dishes ranging from scallop and leek with spruce to lobster with salt-cured rhubarb and lemon verbena. A thrifty approach to meats might find locally shot partridge served first in a broth, followed by its heart and liver with chestnuts, a leg with elderberry and fir, and finally the roasted breast with Pablo beetroot and bread sauce.

An innovative approach to desserts ensures that the latter stages of the production are among the most memorable: mushroom-dusted chocolate ganache with meringue and chocolate/honey pieces, as well as yoghurt ice cream with wood sorrel and Douglas fir oil applied at the table. The rather over-rehearsed mood of service – often a feature of the tasting format – would benefit from relaxing a little.

Three levels of wine flight are offered to accompany the cavalcade of flavours, ranging from ‘experimental and adventurous’, through ‘grand and classic’ to ‘rare and exceptional’, depending on depth of pocket. The first might embrace a Naoussa Xinomavro with that partridge, the second a 2009 Beaune premier cru ‘Les Epenottes’, the last Calera's 2008 Pinot Noir from Sonoma, California.

Read full reviewSee less

G Weller

15 April 2026

The story of the Black Swan, the Banks family and Tommy is very compelling and we were keen to check out whether it was largely marketing hype or something groundbreaking and inspirational. We concluded it was the latter...
The story of the Black Swan, the Banks family and Tommy is very compelling and we were keen to check out whether it was largely marketing hype or something groundbreaking and inspirational. We concluded it was the latter The service was excellent, starting with the warmth of the greeting and extending to the rooms in a nearby converted house and on to the dining experience. There is great attention to detail – for example in the carefully curated bedrooms. Nothing, it seems, is left to chance....
The story of the Black Swan, the Banks family and Tommy is very compelling and we were keen to check out whether it was largely marketing hype or something groundbreaking and inspirational. We concluded it was the latter The service was excellent, starting with the warmth of the greeting and extending to the rooms in a nearby converted house and on to the dining experience. There is great attention to detail – for example in the carefully curated bedrooms. Nothing, it seems, is left to chance. The staff work as a team to maintain high standards of customer service, taking time and trouble to explain every aspect of the tasing menu. For sure there is an agreed script but servers are ready and keen to engage in discussion- for example about the local foraging of wild garlic and the dark arts of the rhubarb triangle. It is here that the knowledge and enthusiasm for food shines through and you can sense that the staff are bound together by the shared purpose of delighting the customer. Sometimes the chef in charge of the course comes out of the kitchen in whites to explain the dish at the table Between us we enjoyed the vegetarian and the meat menu, comparing courses where they differed, for example beef versus onion broth – I would walk a mile to taste either! In terms of standout dishes it was the Lions Main we liked the best – astonishing flavour from a mushroom. We had never tasted Douglas fir and the chicory for chocolate made us remember the Camp Coffee prevalent in the 1950s and used to adorn many a coffee and walnut sponge The breakfast was perhaps a bit more traditional but still there were twists to make it unusual and special. Coffee and bread highly rated. In spite of the strict organisation verging on the performative there is nothing superior or overly fussy in the running of the place, customers are welcomed and made to feel valued and staff look as if they are having fun Of course it's expensive – some might say eye watering with the top drinks package £250 a head ! but that said there is clearly investment in staff training and development, in the nurturing of local talent, in supporting local food producers and in exploring new techniques to bring local ingredients from the field to the table. The business also supports local hospitality and has rescued at least two other village public houses with restaurants. None of this comes cheap. Those of us that are fortunate enough to be able to pay Black Swan prices should do so without grudge, secure in the knowledge that we helping to promote wholesome local food instead of industrialised farming and food outlets putting profit before quality. We should encourage Tommy to innovate and explore new techniques and approaches and applaud the success of everything achieved in Oldstead and beyond.
See MoreSee less

VENUE DETAILS

Main Street
Oldstead
North Yorkshire
YO61 4BLGB

Make a reservation

OTHER INFORMATION

Accommodation, Private dining room, Separate bar, Parking, Deposit required, Pre-payment required

Latest articles